How can we detect life on earth

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

​

The genesis of numerous breakthroughs often originates from a mere spark of curiosity, a phenomenon not uncommon in scientific exploration. In this instance, the inquisitive mind belonged to Carl Sagan, an eminent astronomer and communicator. The source of intrigue was the trajectory of NASA's Galileo spacecraft, which commenced its journey in October 1989 and marked a significant milestone as the first satellite to orbit Jupiter. This curiosity ultimately led to the creation of a groundbreaking paper in the journal Nature, exactly three decades ago, which would revolutionize the approach to seeking extraterrestrial life.

​

This extraordinary opportunity arose from a tragic twist of fate. Nearly four years prior to Galileo's launch, in January 1986, the space shuttle Challenger met with a catastrophic disaster, claiming the lives of seven brave astronauts. Consequently, NASA had to revise its plan for deploying Galileo, abandoning the initial concept of propelling it directly to Jupiter via a liquid-fueled rocket on another space shuttle. Instead, the spacecraft was released more gently from an orbiting shuttle, with engineers ingeniously employing Venus and Earth as gravitational assists to propel it towards its destination.

​

On the 8th of December in 1990, Galileo was scheduled to perform a close flyby of Earth, passing a mere 960 kilometers above its surface. It was at this juncture that Sagan's curiosity transformed into a compelling need to investigate further. Sagan managed to persuade NASA to redirect Galileo's instruments toward our home planet. The resultant paper was titled 'A Search for Life on Earth from the Galileo Spacecraft.' The audacious idea of employing our own planet as a test subject for remote life detection was truly groundbreaking, especially in a time when knowledge of potential life-sustaining environments was scarce. David Grinspoon, a senior scientist specializing in astrobiology at NASA's headquarters in Washington DC, aptly described it as a "science-fiction story wrapped up in a paper."

​

This endeavor occurred at a time when the quest for extraterrestrial life within our solar system was waning. Previous US and Soviet missions in the 1960s and 1970s had dispelled the notion of Venus as a possible habitat for exotic organisms, revealing its hostile conditions. Similarly, Mars appeared as a desolate landscape, far from the fertile planet of the human imagination. In 1990, the existence of concealed oceans on Jupiter's moon, Europa, and Saturn's moon, Enceladus, was yet unknown; discoveries that would later be recognized as potential cradles of extraterrestrial life, thanks to Galileo.

​

Importantly, Sagan and his colleagues adopted a deliberately agnostic approach to the detection of life. Astrobiologist Lisa Kaltenegger, who leads the Carl Sagan Institute at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York, emphasized this approach. While every scientist yearns to discover life, Sagan urged a more cautious perspective, stating that the assumption of life should be the "hypothesis of last resort" in explaining Galileo's findings.

​

Yet, even within this atmosphere of skepticism, the spacecraft delivered remarkable results. It captured high-resolution images of Australia and Antarctica, failing to reveal signs of civilization. However, Galileo's analysis of oxygen and methane in Earth's atmosphere, as well as the detection of a distinctive 'red edge' in the spectrum of reflected sunlight, pointed to the existence of life. It even detected radio signals from Earth, appearing engineered, which Sagan's team cheekily suggested might be the result of intelligent life. The publication of this paper was a pivotal moment, providing a control experiment that was not initially on the radar of many in the scientific community.

​

This unique approach employed by Sagan and his team became a paradigm for searching for life on other planets, influencing subsequent research in the quest for biosignatures. As scientists now embark on the extraordinary journey with the James Webb Space Telescope, the importance of this lesson becomes increasingly apparent. The telescope has begun exploring the atmospheres of numerous exoplanets, searching for the same telltale signs of chemical disequilibrium that Galileo observed in Earth's atmosphere. However, the interpretations of these findings are fraught with challenges, as they could have alternative explanations, and life-friendly conditions are difficult to ascertain.

​

This renewed focus on biosignatures has led to hasty conclusions and overenthusiastic headlines. The recent discovery of methane and carbon dioxide on the exoplanet K2-18 b, for instance, led to premature speculations about potential signs of life. However, the reported findings were preliminary and required further validation. The challenges presented by the complexity of biosignatures call for a structured approach, as proposed by Jim Green in 2021, where evidence for life beyond Earth is assessed on a progressive scale from one to seven.

​

In this evolving field, the search for extraterrestrial life may endure for years or even decades, and the uncertainty persists. Nonetheless, the legacy of Carl Sagan and the lessons from the Galileo mission continue to guide the scientific community in its quest to unravel the mysteries of life beyond our pale blue dot. Just as Voyager 1's iconic "Pale Blue Dot" image reshaped our perspective, Galileo's journey to seek life on Earth has provided a template for the search for life on other planets. It emphasizes the need for patience, rigorous evidence, and the enduring pursuit of understanding our place in the vast cosmos.  [1]